Community

Email Notifications

November Foreclosures: Naughty or Nice?

RealtyTrac released its November foreclosure numbers today and they show foreclosure activity for the month decreased 7 percent from the previous month, down to the lowest level since June (although it was still up 28 percent from November 2007). At first glance this appears to indicate that all the attention to foreclosure prevention on the part of lenders, government entities and others recently may be helping to keep more homeowners from falling into foreclosure. But there are some ominous signs on the horizon that the decrease may simply be the calm before the storm.

“Delinquencies on loans not yet in the foreclosure process jumped to nearly 7 percent in the third quarter, a record high, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association,” said James J. Saccacio, chief executive officer at RealtyTrac. ”And more than half of the homeowners who received loan modifications to reduce monthly mortgage payments in the first half of 2008 are already delinquent on their loans again, according to the U.S. Office of Thrift Supervision. Many of these delinquencies could turn into foreclosures next year.”

View video of panel discussion at National Housing Forum on Dec. 8 with John M. Reich, Director, Office of Thrift Supervision, Sheila C. Bair, Chairman, Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, John C. Dugan, Comptroller, Office of the Comptroller of the Currency, Donald L. Kohn, Vice Chairman, Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve System, James B. Lockhart III, Director, Federal Housing Finance Agency.

Dugan talks about the "re-default" rate at about the 20-minute mark, saying that "over half of all mortgage modifications seem not to be working after just six months."

 

 

Posted: Wed, December 10 2008 11:47 PM by darenb

Comments

Barry Ritholtz said:

Pay attention to the year-over-year data, rather than the noisier monthly data

# December 11, 2008 3:43 AM

darenb said:

No doubt the year-over-year data is more telling; however, the month-over-month data can inform as well -- as long as you don't read too much into it.

# December 11, 2008 8:14 AM

Bill said:

Unfortunately foreclosures and loan modifications are necessary these days.  I suggest you investigate the company offering you any credit related services.  Are the accredited by the Better Business Bureau?  Are their prices reasonable.  Do your leg work and you will be ok.

# December 11, 2008 12:50 PM

Todd Rubinstein said:

Whoa, the YoY numbers are astounding. However, the foreclosure Tsunami looks like it may really hit next spring 09. With the holiday moratorium, States tinkering with the laws, and FDIC and other Fed agencies prolonging the pain, this could drag on 12-15 mos longer than it otherwise would have Most projections are 24-29 more mos). See you on the other side.

# December 11, 2008 2:51 PM

Dan Owen said:

The November drop is expected given the number of banks (and Fannie) that have given those in default a foreclosure 'holiday'.

Expect truly awful numbers in January when the 'holiday' is over and the wave of defaults by Detroit-related people walking away jobless with as much cash as they can preserve.

I find it truly amazing and nauseating that the Republicans gave $700 billion to a bunch of corrupt bankers, but wouldn't give one fortieth (1/40th) that amount to what is left of America's manufacturing infrastructure.

Is this off-topic? Hardly, it will definitely accelerate foreclosures.

# December 12, 2008 5:01 AM

Rick said:

I am not so much concerned about this month or the next few as the subprime mess has already hit and it is obvious that there are many homes in trouble.  I am more concerned since reading a report on www.emptypig.com that referenced last night's 60 minutes report.  They mentioned that there are Alt-A and option arms mortgages and that they will be creating defaults in the coming years to the same extent as the subprime mortgage defaults.  What sounds worse is that these aren't just because of subprime candidates but in fact very devious mortgages designed to entice even marginally qualified candidates and qualified candidates.  

And I agree with Dan about the manufacturing infrastructure. We are bailing out the people that created this mess and benefited from it and we are ignoring the very measures that will help us moving forward.

# December 15, 2008 5:44 PM

darenb said:

I mostly concur with the comments from Rick, Dan and Todd. There has been some artificial suppression of foreclosures that probably could forestall the road to recovery while possibly saving a relatively small percentage of homeowners who are at risk of foreclosure.

The nasty truth is that home prices really have to come down to a truly affordable level and probably overcorrect a bit and become viewed as undervalued in order to convince most buyers that it's safe to get back into the market. Many stakeholders don't want prices to come down (including toxic option ARM and Alt-A mortgage holders). But affordable, even bargain prices, will create a floor of demand that could help the market better weather the next round of foreclosures -- especially if lenders adjust and become better equipped to respond to short sales or agree to meaningful loan modifications. In a sense the farther prices fall in response to this first wave of foreclosures, the less susceptible the market will be to further price declines when the next wave hits.

# December 16, 2008 10:45 AM

R Freeman said:

Does anyone know what will happen to the foreclosed homes that the Fed intends to buy? Will they still be financed by a bank? And since banks require PMI, why are foreclosures causing so many banks to fail?  

 

# December 16, 2008 6:30 PM

BlogChicagoHomes.com said:

DESPITE SURGING FORECLOSURE RATES, HUGE SAVINGS - MANY BUYERS DON'T WANT THE HEADACHE! Here in Chicago

# December 21, 2008 3:44 PM

Philip said:

Foreclosures in November did NOT go down.

November simply had less business days in it.   Please, count the number of business days in both October and November.  Add the foreclosures for both months together and then divide.

You'll find that the "per business day" foreclosure rate was virtually the same for both October and November.  RealtyTrac either doesn't understand their own data, or they're too lazy to analyze.

# December 28, 2008 5:08 PM

Matt Peters said:

In my local area, the legal system — both the courts and the foreclosure attorneys — are getting bogged down and backed up. They have been running over capacity and seem to have hit a wall.

Working with new REO assignments (foreclosed properties in preparation for sale) I had noticed a higher percentage of "incomplete" legal actions when checking the status of my assignments. My inquiries to the foreclosure attorneys revealed invariably that their offices were running way behind on processing.  

New cases are slow to get started when the attorney's offices and courts are taking as long as six to eight weeks to get court approval of the “Special Masters Report and Sale,” from the actual sale on the courthouse steps. It used to be uncommon for that process to take more than a week or two.

Matt Peters

 

# December 31, 2008 8:30 AM

stellaf said:

Hi,

Thanks for sharing.

Stella F.

# February 6, 2009 9:44 PM
Leave a Comment

(required) 

(required) 

(optional)

(required)