A place where you can find out the latest real estate trends, comment and ask questions based on your experiences with the foreclosures market. In addition, we want this blog to develop into a community where you can connect and share ideas with others interested in the foreclosures market.

Community

Email Notifications

Archives

July 2008 - Posts

‘Extreme’ Dream Gone Bust

 

Three years ago Patricia and Milton Harper received a gift courtesy of reality television. ABC’s Extreme Makeover Home Edition came to the rescue, demolishing the Harper’s old run down home with a faulty septic tank and replacing it with a 5,300 square-foot, two-story dream home in Lake City, Georgia.

When the show first aired back on February 20, 2005, the home was the largest ever built in a week by the show. The home, built with the help of 1,800 volunteers and Atlanta-based Beazer Homes, is now scheduled for public foreclosure auction on August 5.

As so many people have done, the Harpers made the unfortunate error of using the home as an ATM machine. The couple borrowed $450,000 in equity as collateral to finance Mr. Harper’s construction business, which went bust. Now the beautiful mansion with a three-car garage on Ahyoka Drive is going to be sold next week on the Clayton County courthouse steps by JPMorgan Chase Bank, according to RealtyTrac.

A published report by the Associated Press says that in addition to building the home with $450,000 worth of donated labor and materials, the partners and employees at Beazer also contributed $250,000 for the family, including scholarships for the three children and a home maintenance fund.

For its part, the ABC television network told the AP that it advises every family on the show to consult with a financial planner after receiving their new home.

Still, for a potential homebuyer or investor looking for a newer property in a suburb of Atlanta, this is probably one of those properties that will go back to the bank as an REO. Most investors won’t touch a property like this, which probably has little or no equity, since they are looking for a discounted price. And most home buyers are looking for a deal below market value. So look for a listing on the local MLS soon.

Published Wed, July 30 2008 3:30 PM by joelc
Home Prices Fall Deeper Into the Abyss

Homeowners across the country may be feeling a bit like Mel Brooks’ character from his movie “High Anxiety” now that Standard and Poor’s has released its May numbers for the S&P/Case-Shiller Home Price Indices.

In the movie, Brooks’ character nervously sweats every time he even thinks about getting into an elevator. Well, the nation’s homeowners are sweating it out now, being taken on the descending elevator ride of their lives, especially those living in markets that experienced the largest gains during the boom years and are now freefalling deep into the elevator shaft.

The S&P figures for May show declines in all 20 metro areas reported for the second straight month — nine with record lows and 10 in double digits. Home prices in its original composite 10 metro areas fell to a new record low, down 16.9 percent from a year ago, while its composite 20 metro areas also reported a record yearly decline of 15.8 percent.

Biggest decliners on a yearly basis were Las Vegas (-28.4 percent) and Miami (-28.3 percent), followed by Phoenix (-26.5 percent), Los Angeles (-24.5 percent), San Diego (-23.2 percent), San Francisco (-22.9 percent) and Tampa (-20.2 percent).

Detroit was down 17.4 percent from May 2007 to a level below where home prices stood back in January 2000.

Washington, Los Angeles, New York and Miami are highlighted in a S&P press release as the best performing markets overall since January 2000.

On a monthly basis, from April to May the worse decliners were Miami (-3.6 percent) and Las Vegas (-2.9 percent).

“The overall real estate market continued to slide in May, with the 10-City and 20-City Composites declining by 1.0 percent and 0.9 percent for the month respectively. Since August 2006 there has not been one month where we have seen overall price increases, as measured by the two Composites,” said David M. Blitzer, Chairman of the Index Committee at Standard & Poor’s, in today’s release.

With home prices continuing to decline, both on a monthly and yearly basis, it stands to reason that distressed homeowners are not out of the woods yet if they need to sell their homes to escape foreclosure.

For potential homebuyers, investors and real estate professionals, it means the flow of foreclosed properties should continue into the indefinite future — at least until home prices stabilize somewhere down the abyss and reverse their direction back up the elevator shaft.

Published Tue, July 29 2008 4:30 PM by joelc
Is Eight Enough?

The number of properties with some sort of foreclosure action against them (default notice, auction notice, bank repossession) has consistently risen for the past eight quarters (see chart). While there have been monthly fluctuations up and down during this time period, the quarterly numbers consistently have been up quarter over quarter, and the most recent quarter was no exception, according to the U.S. Foreclosure Market Report released by RealtyTrac today.

And while this upward trend in foreclosure activity is driven largely by a few populous states with volatile housing markets, there's no doubt the pain is spilling over into many other areas across the country.

“Forty-eight of 50 states and 95 out of the nation’s 100 largest metro areas experienced year-over-year increases in foreclosure activity in the second quarter," said RealtyTrac CEO James J. Saccacio in the press release announcing the Q2 report.

State governments that have gotten past the denial stage and actively addressed the foreclosure issue seem to be reaping the benefits of such foresight. One example is Colorado, whose foreclosure rate ranked No. 1 among the states in 2006, according to RealtyTrac. Some state officials initially took issue with the numbers, which engendered an important debate on how to accurately interpret and measure foreclosure data. But ultimately state officials took action by first investigating the foreclosure data themselves and then by working to curb foreclosures. The Colorado Division of Housing set up a foreclosure hotline to help people facing foreclosure. The state government enacted new laws addressing the issue, one of which gave homeowners more time on the front end of the foreclosure process to try to work out a way to stop or avoid the foreclosure.

Colorado's efforts appear to have had an impact. The state's foreclosure rate was down to No. 5 in the second quarter thanks in part to a 15 percent decrease in activity from the previous quarter. Activity was still up on a year-over-year basis, but at a much slower pace than the increase nationwide.

Late to the party as usual, the federal government is now trying to address the foreclosure issue as part of the mammoth housing bill making its way through Congress this week. President Bush has said he will sign the bill, which would allow many homeowners facing foreclosure to refinance into lower-cost, government-backed loans. The bill also earmarks $4 billion in grants for local communities to buy up foreclosed properties that may be negatively affecting the communities. Whether this bill will actually slow or stop the trend of rising foreclosures is up for debate. We'll certainly be watching to see if the third quarter foreclosure numbers translate into a ninth straight quarterly increase.

View Q2 state data.

View Q2 MSA data.

Published Fri, July 25 2008 2:00 AM by darenb
Michigan Goes Hollywood to Help Homeowners

Lights! Camera! Action!

No it’s not one of the big commercial television networks spending millions of dollars on some game show with a stupid name. Rather, it’s more of a “reality” television show.

The State of Michigan is hitting the airwaves with a cable television show of its own called “House Michigan” aimed at promoting homeownership and everything that entails.

Since January 2006 Michigan has ranked in RealtyTrac’s top 10 states with the greatest foreclosure activity in the nation, most of that time maintaining a position in the top five.

In June 2008 — the most recent monthly ranking available from RealtyTrac — the Great Lakes State ranked fifth nationally, reporting 12,025 properties with foreclosure filings, accounting for 5 percent of the nation’s total foreclosure filings for the month. With one in every 375 Michigan households receiving a foreclosure filing during the month — 1.3 times the national average — the state’s foreclosure rate ranked fifth highest among the 50 states.

With all these distressed homeowners getting into financial trouble, combined with layoffs from the auto industry, it’s understandable that the state government may want to do something to promote homeownership and to educate its citizens about the details of what owning a home really means from a practical standpoint.

In a press release distributed by the Michigan State Housing Development Authority, the goal of the show is to provide programming that will give “realistic advice to improve the quality of life for everyone and lead to vibrant cities and neighborhoods across the state.”

Everything from affordable housing and refinancing a mortgage, to avoiding foreclosures and where to go for help with homelessness and domestic violence will be topics open for discussion on the program.

With unemployment well above the national average, and average home prices continuing to deflate statewide, any information that can help struggling homeowners deal with their situation and become more informed borrowers in the process can only help in these times of financial turmoil that are affecting so many people around the country.

Published Thu, July 24 2008 10:30 AM by joelc
First-Time Buyers Get Help with CA Foreclosure Purchase

First-time homebuyers in California are getting help in purchasing their piece of the American Dream thanks to a public-private partnership and $200 million in bond funds allocated to the California Housing Finance Agency (CalFHA).

Gov. Arnold Schwartzenegger announced Monday that CalFHA’s Community Stabilization Home Loan Program will dole out the money, expected to help as many as 1,000 Californians obtain their piece of homeownership.

But there is a catch!

The catch is buyers have to be willing to buy their dream home in one of the designated areas approved by CalFHA — such as Alameda, Contra Costa and Riverside counties — and the foreclosure property must be specifically set aside for the program and owned by one of the participating lenders — including Wells Fargo, HomeEq, CitiMortgage and Fannie Mae.

The reward for participating in this program is actually pretty sweet, however. The lenders (and hopefully more will come forward as the program gets going) have all agreed to price the properties at 12 percent below market value.

Also, the program will offer financing at a fixed 5.5 percent interest rate for 30 years and without a down payment! However, there is the normal catch here too in that the consequence for no down payment is that borrowers will be required to pay for PMI (private mortgage insurance).They will have to meet CalHFA’s income limits as well.

Will this help slow down the onslaught of foreclosure activity in the state? No! But it could help potential homebuyers looking to RealtyTrac for bargain properties to realize their dream of homeownership if it is the right house in the right place, as determined by CalHFA and its partners.

 

Published Tue, July 22 2008 3:00 PM by joelc
May Home Prices Down 4.8 Percent

Home prices were down again in May, but a few regions of the country experienced a ever-slight uptick in prices from the previous month, giving officials at the Office of Federal Housing Enterprise Oversight (OFHEO) a chance to be cautiously optimistic in the press release announcing the numbers.

"It is very hard to draw conclusions from a one-month number, especially in these uncertain times; but the numbers in the Pacific, East and West North Central Divisions may be good signs," said OFHEO Director James B. Lockhart in the release.

Nationwide, the OFHEO report showed home prices in May were down 0.3 percent from April and down 4.8 percent from May 2007. The three Census Divisions mentioned by Lockhart were the only ones out a total of nine that did not report a monthly decrease.

The Pacific Division, which includes Hawaii, Alaska, Washington, Oregon and California, reported a 0.3 percent increase in home prices from April to May, although the region documented a 14.5 percent decline in home prices from May 2007. The East North Central Division, which includes Michigan, Wisconsin, Illinois, Indiana and Ohio, reported a 0.1 percent monthly increase, but still a 3.7 percent year-over-year decrease in home prices. The West North Central Division, which includes North Dakota, South Dakota, Minnesota, Nebraska, Iowa, Kansas and Missouri, reported no monthly change in home prices.

It will be interesting to see how these home price numbers correlate to the Q2 foreclosure numbers RealtyTrac will be releasing Friday. We'll be posting those numbers as soon as they are available.

Published Tue, July 22 2008 9:09 AM by darenb
Mid-Year Report: Nation Not Over the Hump Yet

As it has in times past, real estate has led this nation into recession, and it will lead us out as well — when the signs are there for a recovery. We’re now mid-way through 2008 and the signs aren’t there yet to say for certain that we’re over the hump and on the way out of recession. But a recession it is nonetheless.

But real estate — housing prices to be precise — is the sign that forecasters at the A. Gary Anderson Center for Economic Research at Chapman University are looking to lead the way back to prosperity.

In their June 2008 issue of the Economic & Business Review, the U.S. Forecast article for 2008-2009 is entitled, “The Recessionary Outlook: Housing Prices Will Determine Its Length and Intensity.”

“The Fed has moved aggressively into a stimulation mode,” said Chapman University President James L. Doti in presenting the national forecast to attendees of the university’s forecast update conference. “There’s no question that the Fed needs to dig in because of the potential for inflation.”

Banks are holding back on all types of lending, the report notes, and probably for good reason considering the $300 billion in write downs already taken by the nation’s financial institutions, with the prospect of more on the way, depending on which direction home prices go in the future.

Median home prices have already dropped 13.6 percent from their peak of $227,333 back in Q3 2005. “The most dramatic decrease since the Great Depression,” Doti noted.

The housing “bubble” which occurred due to the abuse of subprime and other exotic financial vehicles has now burst, causing home prices to decline back to the level where housing affordability is back to the level it was before the subprime boom hit (a home price to income ratio of  3.3), the Chapman report notes.

Other highlights of the Chapman forecast update are:

  • The annual number of housing starts has reached a recent low of one million units. So pent-up demand for housing will increase and quickly cut into the 10+ month inventory of vacant and unsold housing
  • The lagged effects of the housing price drop has reduced household wealth by $2 trillion. This is expected to reduce consumer spending by about $100 billion.
  • The overall impact of the administration’s stimulus checks will be minimal as consumers use a good share of the money to pay down debt
  • Housing prices will depreciate 6.1 percent in 2008 with a mild uptick in 2009
  • The Fed will raise the Federal Funds Rate by 100 basis points (1 percent) in 2009 which will be mirrored in other short-term interest rates
  • Stable to moderately increasing long-term interest rates

“I think it’s going to be a mild recession followed by a mild recovery,” Doti said.

Chapman also has a econometric model in their computer system to predict the outcome of the national election which has a very good record at correctly predicting the next president based on certain economic factors.

As for election 2008, the winner (according to Chapman) will be…..

Barack Obama by a 2.4 percent margin of victory.

What this means for the future of foreclosures in this country? As for the election, it’s hard to tell. As for the economic outlook, if it comes to pass the way the Chapman forecasters are predicting, a mild recovery could lead to a bit of a softening in foreclosure levels. However, this most likely will be countered by the expected reset of interest rates on many more option ARMs this year and next.

Bottom line: we’re not over the hump yet. Foreclosures are here to stay for the foreseeable future.

What do you think? We’d like to hear from you and get your opinions on these economic projections.

Published Mon, July 14 2008 3:15 PM by joelc
Foreclosure Activity Deflating or Just Deferred?

U.S. foreclosure activity in June decreased 3 percent from the previous month but was still up 53 percent from June 2007, according to the RealtyTrac U.S. Foreclosure Market Report released today. The 3 percent decrease may lead some to speculate that the upward trend in foreclosure activity may be nearing an end, but as RealtyTrac CEO James J. Saccacio pointed out in a statement, the year-over-year change is a more indicative number of the overall trend.

"The year-over-year increase of more than 50 percent indicates we have not yet reached the top of this foreclosure cycle," he said.

In fact, the RealtyTrac report has shown month-to-month decreases in previous months, even during the dramatic run-up in foreclosure activity that has occurred over the past year and a half: in February 2008, November 2007, September 2007, June 2007, April 2007, and February 2007.

What may be a better argument -- although certainly not an ironclad case -- that the foreclosure surge is starting to run out of steam is the trend over the past 18 months in YOY percentage changes, broken down by type of foreclosure filing. As can be seen in the chart below, the default and auction categories experienced double- and triple-digit YOY percentage increases for much of 2007. But the increases in those categories started to slow down in 2008. Meanwhile, REO (bank repossession) activity actually decreased on a YOY basis in January and February of 2007 but gradually started to gain momentum in the second half of 2007, and increases in REOs have far outpaced the increases in defaults and auctions in all six months of 2008.

One could argue that this chart shows that the bulk of the properties that were at risk for foreclosure have migrated through the process and are now being repossessed by the foreclosing lenders. There is not a continued massive surge in defaults and auction notices, so once the lenders have disposed of their REO inventory, the real estate market can start to return to normal. On the other hand, some might argue that many properties are still at risk for falling into foreclosure, but the default notices against those properties may have been delayed by artificial means -- for example laws in Colorado, Maryland and Massachusetts requiring lenders to give homeowners more time before initiating foreclosure. Those artificial means may just temporarily be forestalling another wave of defaults that we'll see sometime in the coming months.

We'd like to hear if you buy into either of these theories or have another theory of your own that explains the foreclosure trends.

Published Thu, July 10 2008 1:59 AM by darenb
Write an Essay, Pay Off Your Mortgage

At present, approximately two percent of the outstanding mortgage loans in the U.S. are in some stage of foreclosure, according to RealtyTrac. And who knows how many more may be on the verge of going over the edge anytime soon as subprime loans adjust up to higher interest rates in the next couple of years.

Taking all those people into consideration, it makes for a very large potential pool of distressed homeowners to choose from when judging any kind of a contest offering to pay off someone’s mortgage.

And that is probably what Columbia Pictures is counting on.

According to the Reuters news service, the movie studio, in promoting it’s soon to be released picture “Hancock” starring Will Smith as a “flawed but good-hearted superhero” has decided to hold an essay contest to select one lucky family to have their mortgage paid off.

Offering to pay off up to $360,000 of the winning family’s mortgage debt, the contest requires the entries to be no longer than 200 words on the subject of why they believe they deserve to win the grand prize, Reuters reports.

Considering that any movie of this caliber coming out of a major Hollywood studio garnered a multi-million advertising budget, offering only $360,000 may seem like peanuts.

But to a family facing possibly losing their home to foreclosure, that kind of money can make a huge difference. In some areas of the country it could pay off their entire mortgage, while in others it could mean paying off enough of the debt owed to let them remain in the house and to refinance the balance at a lower interest rate.

Kudos to Columbia Pictures for trying something fresh and different. And good luck to them in choosing the winning entry. Word of this gets around they could be facing thousands if not millions of submissions.

Hopefully Will Smith is on board with the concept. Maybe he will even hand over the check to the winning family. Wouldn’t that be something!

We’re interested in what you think about this kind of “publicity stunt.” Do you see it as totally self-serving on the studio’s part to draw audience to the movie? Do you think they are taking advantage of people who are down and out on their luck?

In any case, you can’t deny there are plenty of cash-strapped families out there that are hurting and could use a quick influx of funds to save their homes.

For more information, and to submit an entry, check out the movie's official website and click on the "Hancock's Helping Hand Mortgage Payoff Contest" button.

Published Wed, July 02 2008 11:00 AM by joelc